The ruling came at the board's regular meeting. Members upheld
zoning Commissioner Gary Ward's decision that the tree house
violates the city's accessory building ordinance.
A lawyer for the Welch family, who built the tree house, then
asked the board to grant them permission to keep the house based
a state ordinance for conditional use and non-conforming use.
Again, the board denied their request.
The Welch family says they don't understand why the board
ruled against them.
Filled with emotion, Scot Welch said, "It's hard to
explain it to the adults. I've had trouble explaining it to
everybody in the city, people in Madison and the surrounding
areas, the CBS Evening News. People from all over the country
are calling us now because of the story that ran this morning.
We cannot explain it."
The Welch's have ten days to file an appeal or to come into
compliance. Their attorney says they will submit their appeal to
the state circuit court within that time.
Scot and Mary Welch built the tree house five years ago for
their children and their entire neighborhood.
The Welch's say before they ever built the structure, they
checked with city officials to see if it met the city's zoning
code and they were assured it did. Shortly after approval that
code changed but the Welch's weren't informed.
In April, zoning officials told the Welch's they would have
to tear their tree house down, because it was in violation of
Clinton's building code. Neighbors and residents have been
petitioning to keep the tree house.